Nearly a million vehicles were never built during the pandemic years. Those cars are not coming back. Here is what that means for dealers and buyers in 2026, and what the smarter operators are doing about it.

If you have been trying to stock a used car lot in Southern Ontario lately, you already know the feeling. The cars you want are harder to find, the auction prices are higher than they should be, and your margins are getting squeezed from both sides. This is not a local problem, and it did not start recently.

The shortage of used vehicles across Canada in 2026 has roots that go back more than five years. Understanding those roots is the first step to sourcing smarter, whether you are a dealer trying to keep your lot full or a buyer trying to understand why the car you want costs more than it did a few years ago.

Part One

Why inventory is still tight: the full picture

A million vehicles that were never built

Before the COVID pandemic, Canada was selling roughly two million new vehicles per year. That was the normal pace. When the pandemic hit in 2020, automakers around the world shut down factories. Semiconductor shortages, supply chain collapses, and workforce disruptions made it impossible to build cars at normal volumes. From 2020 through 2023, Canadian new vehicle sales dropped to between 1.5 million and 1.6 million units per year.

That gap, somewhere close to a million vehicles over those four years, is the engine behind everything happening in the used market right now. Daniel Ross, Senior Manager of Auto Industry Insights at Canadian Black Book, explained it plainly: on average, a new car comes back to the market as a used car about four years after it was originally purchased. That means the vehicles that were never built from 2020 to 2023 are exactly the vehicles that should be showing up on used lots right now in 2024 through 2027.

“Those vehicles are not coming back to the market because they were not sold new.” Daniel Ross, Canadian Black Book, via BNN Bloomberg / The Canadian Press, October 2024

The off-lease pipeline ran dry

One of the most reliable sources of good quality, low-mileage used vehicles has always been lease returns. When a customer finishes a three or four year lease, they hand back a well-maintained vehicle that goes straight back into inventory. Dealerships could count on this pipeline being predictable. That changed completely.

Because so few new vehicles were sold and leased during 2020 to 2022, the number of vehicles coming off lease in 2024 and 2025 is dramatically lower than normal. This is a structural shortage, not a market fluctuation. The vehicles simply were never leased in the first place.

The second part of the problem is what happened to the people who did have leases expiring during the pandemic. Many of them wanted to hand back their car and get something new. But there was nothing new available. So instead of returning the vehicle, they bought it out at the end of the lease. Now those same owners are holding onto vehicles they paid a premium price for, and they are not trading them in either.

Extended lease terms made things worse. Without new vehicles to put customers into, dealerships were extending their clients’ leases rather than letting them expire. Those vehicles stayed off the used market even longer.

The 4 to 12 year segment is where the pain is worst

The UCDA’s January 2026 dealer survey, conducted with DesRosiers Automotive Consultants, identified the 4 to 12 year old vehicle segment as the hardest hit. Many dealers across Canada reported moderate to extreme difficulty sourcing inventory in that age range.

For most independent used car dealers in Southern Ontario, that is exactly the segment that matters most. Vehicles in that age range are what everyday Canadian buyers can actually afford and what financing programs work well for. The shortage hits dealers and buyers at the same time, in the same segment.

Canadians are keeping their cars longer

Trade-ins are one of the main ways used inventory flows back to independent dealers. When a customer buys a new vehicle, they trade in their old one. When a customer upgrades to a different used vehicle, they trade in what they were driving. That cycle has always been a meaningful source of stock.

But Canadians are holding onto their vehicles longer than ever. Economic uncertainty, high vehicle prices, and elevated interest rates have made people more reluctant to change vehicles. In Quebec, the average vehicle age now exceeds 9.8 years, which is a reasonable proxy for what is happening nationally. Fewer trade-ins mean fewer vehicles moving through the system. The pipeline slows down at every point.

Cross-border competition and tariff pressure

There is also a pressure from across the border that gets less attention but has had a real impact on Canadian used vehicle supply. When the Canadian dollar is low, Canadian vehicles become attractively priced for American buyers. Andrew King of DesRosiers Automotive Consultants has noted that around 300,000 used units per year have been flowing south to the United States in recent years, drawn by the exchange rate advantage.

On top of that, the ongoing trade conflict between Canada and the United States has added uncertainty throughout the industry. TD Economics noted in its February 2026 Canadian Automotive Outlook that elevated trade uncertainty is likely to continue weighing on the industry as the first review of CUSMA takes place, and the process promises to be extensive.

Part Two

The numbers right now

Survey data published in early 2026 by the UCDA and DesRosiers Automotive Consultants gives the clearest picture of where the Canadian used vehicle market stands.

Those numbers are striking. Nine out of ten dealers in Canada saw no improvement or an actual worsening of their sourcing conditions heading into 2026. Only about one in ten saw things get better. This is not a market where a few unlucky dealers are struggling. It is a market where the structural conditions are challenging for everyone.

What dealers sold in 2025, and what they expect in 2026

The same survey found that franchised new vehicle dealers averaged 354 used vehicle sales per location in 2025, while independent dealers averaged 173. Both groups are optimistic about the year ahead. Franchised stores are projecting an average of 405 units in 2026, and independents are targeting an average of 201. That represents a roughly 15% improvement across the sector.

The demand is clearly there. Canadians need vehicles. More of them are financing, not fewer. The challenge for dealers in 2026 is purely on the sourcing side. If you can get the right cars at the right price, buyers are waiting.

Where is the inventory actually coming from?

The survey revealed a significant structural difference in how franchised and independent dealers are finding their used vehicles. Franchised dealers are winning the consumer sourcing race. They acquired 65.4% of their used inventory directly from consumers through trade-ins connected to new vehicle sales. Auctions accounted for just 17.9% of their supply.

Independent dealers tell a different story. Auctions are still their primary channel at 50.6% of supply. Direct from consumers accounts for 22.4%, and the balance comes from wholesalers and other sources.

That gap tells an important story. Independent dealers still rely heavily on the auction lane, while franchised dealers have built strong direct-to-consumer pipelines. In a market where auction supply has shrunk and auction prices have climbed, the dealers who can shift even a portion of their sourcing toward direct consumer buying are in a much stronger position.

Used car prices: where things stand

The supply shortage has kept used car prices well above where they were before the pandemic. AutoTrader.ca data showed that the average used car was priced at around $35,754 in late 2024, compared to about $18,900 in December 2019. That is roughly double in five years. More recent data from early 2025 put the average listing price at about CAD $37,500.

Analysts are not forecasting a return to pre-pandemic prices. Canadian Black Book says the market is beginning to stabilize, with depreciation becoming more predictable, but elevated values are expected to persist. For dealers, this means acquisition costs stay high. For buyers, it means financing the right vehicle at the right monthly payment matters more than ever.

Part Three

How to source smarter: what the leading dealers are doing

The inventory problem is real. But it is not unsolvable. Across Canada and the United States, the dealers who are winning the inventory battle in 2026 are the ones who have moved away from purely reactive sourcing and built proactive systems for finding vehicles before they ever hit the auction block.

The auction lane is no longer a reliable primary strategy

For many independent dealers in Ontario, the auction has been the go-to sourcing method for decades. When you needed to fill holes on the lot, you went to the lane. That model has eroded significantly over the past several years.

According to vAuto and industry data reported by AutoAlert, auction sourcing fell from roughly 27% of dealer used inventory in 2019 to approximately 18% today. That is one third of the auction’s share of dealer sourcing evaporating in just a few years. What used to be a dependable supplemental source has become constricted and expensive.

The Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index remained elevated, up 6.3% year over year as of mid-2025, which means dealers are paying more at auction while competing with more buyers for fewer vehicles. As scarcity drives up wholesale prices, independent dealers often end up overbidding or settling for higher-mileage stock that creates reconditioning challenges.

Direct consumer buying and dealer-to-dealer networks

Dealer-to-dealer wholesale and direct-from-consumer buying campaigns have become essential strategies for independent operators who cannot rely on trade-ins the way franchised stores can.

Direct consumer buying means reaching out proactively to past customers, running community buying campaigns, and using online platforms to make purchase offers to private sellers before those sellers decide to try selling on their own or trading in somewhere else. The acquisition price is often better for both sides than what the auction would produce, and the vehicle history is usually more transparent.

Instant trade-in platforms, which let a dealer make a price offer online, get the seller to accept, and arrange pickup without the customer coming to the lot, have become increasingly important sourcing tools in a tight market. The convenience draws more sellers and reduces the friction that can cause a deal to fall apart.

Mining your own customer database

Every dealership has something that often goes completely underused as an inventory source: its own customer history. The average dealership has thousands of sold customers in its CRM and DMS records. Those customers are driving vehicles whose full history the store already knows. Many of them are sitting in positive equity positions on their current vehicle and have no idea.

According to Cars Commerce, 56% of car shoppers plan to trade in their current vehicle when purchasing their next one. That is not just a retail trend; it is an acquisition pipeline sitting in every dealership’s database. The problem is that most stores wait passively for those customers to walk back in. By then, the customer may already be shopping elsewhere, holding multiple online offers, or close to making a decision with a competitor.

The dealers who are winning identify which specific customers are realistically positioned to upgrade, based on factors like current loan payoff, estimated vehicle value, equity position, vehicle age, and service history. Then they reach out proactively with a genuine offer before the customer starts shopping. This approach requires no auction fees, no transport costs, and no competing bids from other buyers.

The service drive as a sourcing channel

When a vehicle comes in for service, the dealership has a direct, trusted interaction with an owner who may be thinking about their next move. The service advisor already knows the vehicle condition. The customer is already on the lot. That moment, handled honestly and at the right time, is a low-cost acquisition opportunity that bypasses every step of the auction process.

This channel is probably the most underleveraged in the independent dealer world. It does not need to be a hard sell. A straightforward, honest conversation about what a vehicle is worth and what the customer’s options look like can result in a clean purchase at a fair price for everyone involved.

What is coming: used EV lease returns

There is one new supply channel that is beginning to open for the first time. Canadian Black Book anticipates that used EV supply will grow in 2026 as off-lease battery electric vehicles start returning to the market, accounting for roughly 11% of total used vehicle supply for the year. That is a meaningful and new channel that was not available even two years ago.

The UCDA survey found that the majority of dealers currently report BEV and PHEV sales accounting for just 0 to 5% of their used volume. Most dealers are not yet actively engaged with used EVs. The dealers who build the knowledge, the processes, and the financing relationships to handle used EV inventory now will have access to a supply channel that their competitors may not yet be equipped to use.

---

Questions buyers and dealers ask most